Which is Right for You?
One of the biggest choices in 2025 is whether to go with a generalist ERP (SAP, Microsoft Dynamics, Infor, Oracle) or a specialist ERP (Genius ERP, ProShop, JobBOSS², BatchMaster).
Specialist ERPs are purpose-built. Manufacturing ERPs offer features designed with the shop floor in mind, and tend to be faster to implement and cost less. For example, Genius ERP, built by manufacturers, supports a wide range of shops—from ETO and MTO to job shops and beyond. ProShop ERP is tailored for aerospace job shops, while BatchMaster focuses on process manufacturing.
Generic ERPS are powerful. They’re built to support every type of business operation—not just manufacturing—across multiple industries and global markets. Large enterprises often need that level of flexibility. The tradeoff is higher cost, added complexity, and longer implementation. SAP S/4HANA, for example, excels at coordinating supply chains across continents, but most mid-sized shops don’t need—or want—that kind of overhead.
How to decide?
If you’re an enterprise manufacturer with thousands of employees, a generalist like SAP or Infor might make sense.
If you’re a small-to-mid-sized manufacturer, a manufacturing-specific ERP usually delivers more value because it fits your processes out of the box.
If you’re ready to dive deeper into what makes a manufacturing-specific ERP different, check out our Beginner’s Guide to Manufacturing ERPs